Interactive Demonstrations for Statistics Education on the World Wide Web

R. Webster West and R. Todd Ogden
University of South Carolina

Journal of Statistics Education v.6, n.3 (1998)

Copyright (c) 1998 by R. Webster West and R. Todd Ogden, all rights reserved. This text may be freely shared among individuals, but it may not be republished in any medium without express written consent from the authors and advance notification of the editor.

Let's Make a Deal Applet

As a motivating example behind the discussion of probability, an applet has been developed that allows students to investigate the Let's Make a Deal paradox. This paradox is related to a popular television show in the 1970's. In the show, a contestant was given a choice of three doors, one of which hid a prize. The other two doors hid gag gifts like a chicken or a donkey. After the contestant chose an initial door, the host of the show then revealed a gag gift behind one of the two unchosen doors, and asked the contestant if he or she would like to switch to the other unchosen door. The question is, should the contestant switch? Do the odds of winning increase by switching to the remaining door?

The intuition of most students tells them that each of the doors, the chosen door and the unchosen door, are equally likely to contain the prize so that there is a 50-50 chance of winning with either selection. This, however, is not the case. The probability of winning by using the switching technique is 2/3, while the chance of winning by not switching is 1/3. The easiest way to explain this to students is as follows. The probability of picking the wrong door in the initial stage of the game is 2/3. If the contestant picks the wrong door initially, the host must reveal the remaining empty door in the second stage of the game. Thus, if the contestant switches after picking the wrong door initially, the contestant will win the prize. The probability of winning by switching then reduces to the probability of picking the wrong door in the initial stage, which is clearly 2/3.

Despite a very clear explanation of this paradox, most students have difficulty understanding the problem. It is very difficult to conquer the strong intuition that most students have in this case. As a challenge to students who don't believe the explanation, an instructor may ask the students to actually play the game a number of times by switching and by not switching and to keep track of the relative frequency of wins with each strategy. An applet has been developed that allows students to repeatedly play the game and keep track of the results. The applet is given below.

Within the applet, the computer plays the role of the host. Upon loading the applet, students are asked to pick a door by clicking the mouse on the proper region. After the initial pick, the computer reveals one of the two gag gifts by "opening" a door and displaying a picture of a donkey behind one of the numbers. The students then have the option of staying with their initial selection or switching to the remaining door. The computer keeps track of the number of times the game is played with each strategy and the number of times the game is won with each strategy. This information is displayed at the bottom of the applet after each game. Using empirical techniques, the student is then able to see the strategy with the highest probability of winning as the relative frequencies converge to the true probabilities. An instructor may use this game to motivate the idea of repeated trials as a means for investigating a random phenomenon.

Graphics by Scott Street, Department of Statistics, University of South Carolina
Return to West and Ogden Paper | Return to Table of Contents | Return to the JSE Home Page